National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
National college for DUI Defense
Lead Counsel
Super Lawyers
Martindale-Hubbell AV Preminent - 2018
Best Law Firms 2014
DUI Defense Lawyers Association
ABA Member 2020
Alabama Criminal Defense Lawyers Association
Certificate of Membership Top 100
Top 100 The National Trial Lawyers

Violation of Due Process of Law: What It Means and How to Challenge It

What Is Due Process of Law?

Mark and Whitney Polson, criminal defense attorneys, standing in front of Polson & Polson office.

Due process of law is a constitutional guarantee. The government cannot take away a person's life, liberty, or property without fair legal procedures. This protection is one of the most fundamental rights in the American legal system. A violation occurs when the government fails to follow these required safeguards.

Two provisions of the U.S. Constitution establish this right. The Fifth Amendment prohibits the federal government from depriving a person of life, liberty, or property without due process. The Fourteenth Amendment extends the same protection against state governments, including Alabama.

Due process takes two forms. Procedural due process requires fair procedures before the government acts. This means adequate notice, a meaningful hearing, and a neutral decision-maker.

Substantive due process goes further. It protects certain fundamental rights from government interference regardless of how fair the procedures may be.

Common Examples of a Violation of Due Process of Law

Due process violations in criminal cases take many forms. These are among the most common.

Failure to provide adequate notice of charges. A defendant has the right to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation. Both the Sixth Amendment and the Alabama Constitution say so. Charging documents can be vague or incomplete. That can deprive a defendant of the ability to prepare a meaningful defense.

Denial of the right to be heard or present a defense. Courts must give defendants a real chance to tell their side. Blocking a defendant from calling witnesses or presenting evidence may violate this core protection.

Use of coerced confessions. A confession obtained through threats, physical force, or prolonged psychological pressure violates due process. Courts routinely exclude statements that were not given voluntarily.

Suppression of exculpatory evidence. Under Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, the prosecution must disclose favorable evidence that is material to guilt or punishment. Withholding such evidence is known as a Brady violation. It is one of the most serious due process breaches in criminal law.

Biased or conflicted judge. Due process requires a fair trial in a fair tribunal. No judge may try a case in which he has an interest in the outcome. A prosecutor's conflict is handled under different rules, but misconduct can still taint a proceeding.

Denial of right to counsel at a critical stage. The Sixth Amendment right to counsel attaches at critical stages of a prosecution. It binds Alabama courts through the Fourteenth Amendment. Questioning a defendant after charges without counsel present can violate that right. Denying access to a lawyer before a key hearing raises the same problem.

Use of unreliable identification procedures. Suggestive lineups or photo arrays can steer a witness toward one suspect. That can produce unreliable identifications. A suggestive procedure alone does not require exclusion. Courts weigh whether the identification was reliable under all the circumstances.

Vague criminal statutes. Due process requires a criminal law to define the offense clearly enough that ordinary people can understand what it prohibits. A law that fails that test can be struck down as vague. Punishing conduct retroactively is barred by a separate rule, the ban on ex post facto laws.

Procedural vs. Substantive Due Process

The difference between procedural and substantive due process matters in criminal defense. Each protects against a different kind of government overreach.

Procedural due process asks: did the government follow fair procedures? The test has three key parts. First, the defendant must receive adequate notice. Second, the defendant must have a meaningful opportunity to be heard. Third, the decision-maker must be impartial. When any of these safeguards is missing, the process itself falls short.

A revocation hearing held without notifying the defendant of the evidence against them could violate procedural due process.

Substantive due process asks a different question. Does the government have the power to act at all? Even with perfect procedures, the government cannot infringe on certain fundamental rights without compelling justification. A statute that criminalizes constitutionally protected conduct may violate substantive due process. This is true regardless of how fairly it is enforced.

Both forms of due process apply in Alabama criminal cases. The Fourteenth Amendment provides these protections. A strong defense finds the type of violation that occurred. It then shapes the legal challenge to fit.

Denial of Due Process of Law in Criminal Cases

Due process violations can surface at every stage of a criminal prosecution. Knowing where these violations usually arise helps defendants and their lawyers spot issues early.

At arrest. An arrest or detention without probable cause violates the Fourth Amendment, which reaches Alabama officers through the Fourteenth Amendment. An unreasonably prolonged stop can also raise concerns. Evidence from an unlawful arrest could be suppressed.

At charging. A charge built on a statute too vague to give fair notice can be challenged on due process grounds. Selective prosecution is a separate claim, judged by equal protection standards. A charging decision may not rest on race, religion, or another arbitrary classification.

At the pretrial stage. Discovery violations rank among the most common pretrial due process issues. When the prosecution fails to turn over favorable evidence, the defense cannot prepare well. Denial of a timely bail hearing may also raise constitutional questions.

At trial. Due process issues at trial include jury bias and denial of the right to cross-examine witnesses. Prosecutorial misconduct can also occur. This includes making inflammatory statements unsupported by evidence. Each of these problems can undermine the fairness of the proceeding.

At sentencing. A court that relies on inaccurate information when imposing a sentence may violate due process protections. Alabama's rules of criminal procedure also require the court to let the defendant speak before sentence is imposed. That step is known as allocution. The Supreme Court has held that skipping it is not by itself a constitutional error. These protections extend through the final stages of a case.

Empty jail cell with barred door and metal bunk, illustrating criminal penalties.

How to Challenge a Due Process Violation

Defendants have several ways to raise due process claims. The options depend on when the violation occurred and when it is discovered.

Pretrial motions. Many due process challenges are raised before trial. A motion to dismiss may argue that the charges themselves are constitutionally deficient. A motion to suppress may seek to exclude evidence obtained through unconstitutional means. Examples include coerced confessions or evidence from an illegal search.

Trial objections. A due process issue can arise during trial. The defense must then object on the record to preserve the issue. Failing to raise a timely objection may waive the right to challenge the error later.

Direct appeal. After a conviction, a defendant may appeal and argue that due process violations affected the outcome. Appellate courts review the trial record. They decide whether errors occurred and whether they were harmful.

Post-conviction remedies. Some due process violations may be raised through post-conviction proceedings. These include newly discovered evidence or prosecutorial misconduct that was not apparent at trial.

Timing is critical. Many due process claims must be raised at a set point in the case. Missing that window could result in waiver. A defendant who suspects a violation should act fast. Talk to a criminal defense attorney to protect your rights.

Due Process Protections Under Alabama Law

Alabama defendants receive due process protection from two sources. The Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution prohibits any state from depriving a person of life, liberty, or property without due process. The Alabama Constitution carries its own due process language in its declaration of rights.

Alabama courts recognize due process claims across the full spectrum of criminal proceedings. Under Alabama's criminal procedure framework, defendants may challenge unlawful arrests and improper charging decisions.

They may also challenge discovery abuses, trial errors, and sentencing problems.

Alabama defendants are protected by both constitutions. Alabama courts read the state guarantee as coextensive with the federal one, so the same standard usually decides the claim. The procedures, standards, and deadlines for these challenges vary. They depend on the nature of the violation and the stage of the case. A criminal defense attorney who knows Alabama courts can see which claims apply. They can also explain how to raise them.

Attorney Mark Polson in a courtroom with Super Lawyers and Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent badges.

Speak With an Alabama Criminal Defense Attorney About Your Due Process Rights

Do you believe your constitutional rights were violated during an arrest, investigation, or prosecution in Alabama? That concern deserves prompt attention. Speaking with a criminal defense attorney early could make a real difference. Many due process challenges must be raised at set points in a case. Waiting too long may result in waiving claims that could otherwise strengthen your defense.

Polson & Polson, P.C. focuses on federal criminal and state criminal defense throughout Alabama. Our attorneys can review the facts of your case. We can spot possible due process issues. We can explain the options you may have in your case.

Contact Polson & Polson, P.C. for a free consultation to discuss your case and your rights.

Free Call 24-hour contact banner with phone number 205-871-8838.

Frequently Asked Questions About Due Process Violations

What Is Considered a Violation of Due Process of Law?

A violation of due process of law occurs when the government deprives a person of life, liberty, or property without following fair legal procedures. It also occurs when the government infringes on fundamental rights without sufficient justification. Common examples include coerced confessions and suppression of favorable evidence. Others include denial of the right to counsel and biased proceedings. The facts of each case decide whether a constitutional violation occurred. Talk to a criminal defense attorney about your case.

What Happens if Your Due Process Rights Are Violated in a Criminal Case?

The consequences depend on the nature and severity of the violation. A court may suppress evidence obtained through unconstitutional means. This could weaken the prosecution's case. In some cases, a conviction may be reversed on appeal. The remedy depends on when the violation occurred, how it affected the case, and whether it was properly raised. An attorney can review whether that violation may warrant relief.

Can a Criminal Case Be Dismissed for a Due Process Violation?

A criminal case may be dismissed for a due process violation in certain circumstances. If a due process violation is severe enough to fundamentally undermine the fairness of the proceeding, a court may dismiss the charges. Examples include egregious prosecutorial misconduct or the destruction of critical evidence in bad faith. However, dismissal is seen as a strong remedy. Courts save it for the most serious violations. Many due process issues result in other remedies rather than outright dismissal. Evidence suppression is one of them.

What Is the Difference Between Procedural and Substantive Due Process?

Procedural due process requires the government to follow fair procedures. This means providing notice and a hearing before depriving someone of life, liberty, or property. Substantive due process protects certain fundamental rights from government interference regardless of the procedures used. Both apply in criminal cases. A procedural claim challenges how the government acted. A substantive claim challenges whether the government had the constitutional authority to act at all.

Client Reviews

Whitney Polson is a no-nonsense attorney who delivered exactly what he said he would on my case...thank you so much sir...I would definitely recommend anyone facing a DUI to retain this man.

D.B.

If you are looking for an attorney I must recommend Mark Polson of Polson & Polson. My case was successfully moved from a February to a December court date and was dismissed. I am extremely please with the way this firm handled the case and was able to secure the dismissal. Thank you again to Polson...

Julie C.

Wow! I never could have hoped for our lawyer to work as fast as he did but Whitney was lightning fast! Very attentive to the details, never left me hanging along the journey-I used online reviews in choosing him and now I want to pass that on-if you need a lawyer (ours was a traffic court case with...

Claire B.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Case Evaluation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 Decades of Courtroom Experience
Fill out the contact form or call us at (205) 871-8838 to schedule your free case evaluation.

Leave Us a Message

Payment Plans Available

American Express LogoVisa LogoDiscover LogoMastercard Logo